Sunday, February 13, 2011

Mystical Healing...Are they real and safe?

http://zonbebas.com/
just for laugh ok...nothing personal

Hi all...
sorry to keep this blog very dormant

Mystical healing or what should i say...spiritual healing, bomoh, shamans

Do you believe in this phenomenon?

As a Muslim, I believe there are spiritual entities living among us.....not Ghost for sure

I believe that illnesses are from GOD willing and the cure is of GOD willing as well

There are a lot of psychological effects behind each successful spiritual healing....that is What Scientists explain...or if you ever heard of PLACEBO EFFECT...similar.

Reasons:
1. When we strongly believe that we will get healed after seeing any spiritual healing...then our mighty brain will do the rest to follow that

2. Some diseases will go off after some time...what a coincidence... the time you see a spiritual healer..that time is just right for a person who is about to get healed without any help even

3. am thinking of other reasons (in the process)..ha..ha..

.... my stance is.... like this

We can always look for the cures for our illness elsewhere, either it is a second opinion or seeking spiritual help BUT please do not ENDANGER yourself by doing that...you know what is not right ...common sense thing

Delaying a proper treatment can be very bad....for example...in the case of cancer.
Not all cancer are the same.....

I will not further write...prefer any question...i will answer as soon as possible...
I need your views as well as part of my learning....

Dr Redduan

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

menarik juak topik tuk ...

my personal view:

benda2 spiritual mmg wujud ...sebab kmk pun pernah berubat makei azan dan ayatul kursi and it works ....

i mean daripada x dpt mengucap kalimah syahadah terus dpt mengucap....doc, adakah seorg Islam yg menjaga sembahyang 5 waktu sengaja atau main2 secara psikologi untuk sik dpt ngucapkah?
setelah berubat spiritually , baruk dpt mengucap kalimah syahadah ...

very hard to say benda2 mcmtuk doc...nang susah juak nak carik org pandei ngubat ya ...like u said the danger is there...tapi sikkan nak ngagak doctor di klinik bila sik dpt mengucap , sik dpt dengar azan ...kan?

dpt bait drpd sakit spiritual adalah satu rahmat ...mungkin doa dari ibubapa dan keluarga dimakbulkan Tuhan untuk kembali sihat spiritually ...

Dr Redduan said...

Yes I agree with your statement
Sik lah nak ngagak doktor mun sik dapat ngucap nak...

But maybe i did not make it clear enough...
Kalau kita memang tak sihat secara fizikal...then seek medical opinion first.

but if it is something spiritual and cannot be explained...kelak jumpa doctor and banyak doctor kinek tuk sik faham benda macam tuk kelak sidak madah penyakit psychiatry indah kelak...
or what we call as delusions and hallucinations

I am not totally against spiritual healing...but our akidah must be right like what you said....doa or prayer

Just something to think about...kenak sidak alim ulama never get this gangguan spiritual...never heard of such problem happens to them....

thanks for your comments.

Bella Luna said...

my younger sister which is now in primary 3 just transfered to a mission school not long ago. actually nya ya dah transfered last year, end of last year, about 2 weeks gik mok school holidays, to be exact. so she had to bid sudden farewell dengan kawan lamak.

i noticed bila first and second days nya kat sia, she was just fine. but then she started to behave in a way that i find weird. she kept on clinging onto my mom, crying, etc. and until now her attendance are very worrying.imagine selang brapa hari mesti ada nya skipped schools. n she always complained about having stomachache, nausea, etc. i asked her once if she wanted to return to her old school but she just said no. she just missed her friends and that was all. we even brought her to meet her friends once in a while but still, she couldn't adapt herself to the new environment. i find it weird because she's not that kind of person. she gets along with ppl very easily, and she can attach to her new surroundings easily bah, like her tuition place, tempat ngaji nya, cepat bah doc. that's why i said i find it strange.

i couldn't help but to worry until i made a research online n find out that my sis probably suffered a school phobia called didaskaleinophobia.

after knowing this, my mom planned to take her to consult a psychiatrist who can deal with this type of problems but we don't have much knowledge on how can we find any here in kuching. my mom talked to her teacher about this, and the teachers even did some acts, but to no avail.

my mom's last choice was to seek for ustaz or someone that can heal this sort of thing, and according to my mom who consulted the ustaz, my sister has this 'lemah semangat' thing on herself, and (not to be racist), this semangat is known to have been wandering around an old cemetery at the back of the school, that had turned my sister the way she was behaving. i didn't get this point clear enough cause, kita xtauk gne rupa semangat ya nak raon2 betol x?

i somehow don't get it, doc, like you said, kita xpat nak madah gilak benda2 macam tok but we know this kind of thing really exist. but then, i'm just confused whether my sis's problem have something to do with EITHER psychology problem like the ones we read in school pobia articles (because my sis has most of the symptoms),, OR lemah semangat like what the ustaz has said.

my sis is now in a process of healing.

but yalah tek, if we were to seek for medical treatment first at that time, do you think doc will say that this has something to do with semangat? mesti nya madah my sis could be school phobic, right? and if we didn't come up with the idea to seek for that ustaz's help, do you think doctors can cure my sis's phobia?


well, just my 2 long cents. it's confusing, really, i know, but i'm just trying to get this right. i just don't know whether my sister ya nang school phobic or lemah semangat. if kmk org ada agak psychiatrist regarding the problem, we can see the difference of the results, of which one yang menjadi nak?

anyway, thanks for sharing this post. :)

Dr Redduan said...

hi Nurul
Kamek rasa adik kitak ada adjustment problem...mungkin ada benda yang nya sik suka kat sekolah baru ya...I dont know what is it...kali jumpa kawan yang sik familiar or kena 'buli' or diasingkan...sebab di sekolah baru ya mungkin they are not that friendly to her because they have their old friend already...it is different if everybody is new to each other...sidak lain maybe think that she is orang baru...that is why ur sis rasa macam sik dilayan kali...and that make her not that happy....

these things will change...just that we need to continuosly support her...

Mun kita nak ngembaknya jumpa psychiatrist kita boleh ngagak Sebayor Clinic depan Wisma Saberkas..there are few UNIMAS psychiatrist that can discuss this issues...jangan salah anggap...bukan sis kitak ada penyakit jiwa...just that this things can happens to anybody in such circumstances...maybe the
doctors there can openly discuss the issues related to your sis easily and with enough experience from their expertise background.

the lemah semangat thing...mmm...i dont think so at this stage but if things get worse...we can always go for both ways of treatment...medical counselling and bawa jumpa ustaz at the same time...not the bomoh...:)

thanks for ur comments

azizi said...

mek setuju juak ngan ktk. medically or spiritually, kita nangga sama ada ya sik bertentangan dengan syarak islam. asal nya sik menyelewengkan, ok la. boleh d terimak..

Dr Redduan said...

thanks for your comment azizi

Blossom L. said...

Hi Doctor Redduan, Is me Blossom Liew,you still remeber me?Last time you help me inject for the cevaric medicine lol... recently i saw your email on the clinic card,so i just try type it and found your blog...so great to find you here..how are you recently?

From: Blossom Liew

Dr Redduan said...

Hi Miss Liew
sure..i remember
how are you..good to know that you found me here...sorry long time already not updating...but i am actively visiting my facebook account...search for klinik cahaya then..
have a great day

Anonymous said...

Hi. Went to your clinic today on 13th of December 2011 at 2.10 pm. Saw one of your staff was on the phone so I waited for her to finish jet conversation. Another staff went in and I asked her whether you are coming by anytime soon. She held her five fingers at my face and said she doesn't know and she has to ask the tiger person about that. Few other patients came in and still your staff was on the phone. When she finally stopped, she called the patients who came later than me and completely ignored my existence. Thanks for making my day worse.

Dr Redduan said...

hi..to anonymous
i am very sorry to hear your story
will look into this matter seriously
i apologize again...just read ur notes in here...long time i did not update the site
i realized not only you complains...i received more and more complains from others...will build up from there...thank you